The Twelve Tribes of Hattie by Ayana Mathis

The Twelve Tribes of Hattie - Ayana MathisThe Twelve Tribes of Hattie – Ayana Mathis
Hutchinson, Random House, 2013
Review copy from Netgalley

Buy: Amazon | Bookdepository *

The Twelve Tribes of Hattie is the story of Hattie Shepherd who moves from Georgia to Philadelphia as part of the Great Migration. Her story spans many decades, from the 1920s to the 1980s.

Aged 17, Hattie’s story begins with the death of her twin babies, Philadelphia and Jubilee. Hattie’s disappointments in life have just begun, but the death of her first children will cast a shadow over most of what happens afterwards. Her husband cheats and squanders their money which leaves her and the long row of children they have together in poverty. The rest of the story is told through the alternating viewpoints in which these children usually take the lead. Most of them face difficulties in live, and they often remember their strong, but mostly unloving mother, during these episodes. While most of the story actually is not told from Hattie’s point of view, and is usually removed from the direct domestic sphere of Hattie’s household, this novel consisting of 10 chapters all seemingly telling a different but intertwined story in the end all revolve around Hattie in some way or other.

However, The Twelve Tribes of Hattie is more than a story about one family and ultimately the lasting impact of one mother. It is packed with larger themes such as a returning reflection on the nature of the US south:

“He thought of the South as a single undifferentiated mass of states where the people talked too slow, like August, and left because of the whites, only to spend the rest of their lives being nostalgic for the most banal and backwoods things: paper shell pecans, sweet gum trees, gigantic peaches.”

And a commentary on religious belief. Religion recurs in the stories of Hattie’s children, but in the end also appears in the final pages as a metaphor, or perhaps as commentary, on her broader outlook on life, while also posing the question if Hattie’s individual life could be read as the lives of many women of the great immigration:

“She had been angry with her children, and with August, who’d brought her nothing but disappointment. Fate had plucked Hattie out of Georgia to birth eleven children and establish them in the North, but she was only a child herself, utterly inadequate to the task she’d been given. No one could tell her why things had turned out the way they had, not August or the pastor or God himself. Hattie believed in God’s might, but she didn’t believe in his interventions. At best, he was indifferent. God wasn’t any of her business, and she wasn’t any of his. In church on Sundays she looked around the sanctuary and wondered if anyone else felt the way she did, if anyone else was there because they believed in the ritual and the hymn singing and good preaching more than they believed in a responsive, sympathetic God.”

The thing is, perhaps I like the idea of The Twelve Tribes of Hattie better than its execution. The alternating viewpoints sometimes almost lead you to believe that you are reading ten different stories that are not altogether a coherent whole. The family tree becomes somewhat confusing sometimes. The fact that as a reader you only see episodes from each of these lives sometimes interferes with a deeper understanding of the characters – something I would have liked a little more of. And, as is often the case, some of the characters’ stories did more for me than others. I felt I persevered, and had to tell myself to do so, through parts of this book. And perhaps the only chapters that glued this book together, and “saved” it for me, were the rather touching beginning and ending.

There is some wonderful prose, some wonderful insight into what emotions, stress, and social circumstances will do to family life while also underlining love next to heartbreak.. And yet, The Twelve Tribes of Hattie failed to grab me, convince me, as such a heartbreaking story might be expected to do.

Other Opinions: BookLust, Boston Bibliophile,  Book Monkey, Reading on a Rainy Day,  Devourer of Books, nomadreader, A Bookish Way of Life, Lovely Trees Reads,  Amy’s Book Obsession, Sam Still Reading, Follow the Thread, Bibliophile by the Sea, Curled Up with a Good Book and a Cup of Tea.
Did I miss your post about this book? Let me know and I will add it to the list!

* These are affiliate links. If you buy a product through either of them, I will receive a small percentage of the purchase price.

4 thoughts on “The Twelve Tribes of Hattie by Ayana Mathis

  1. zibilee

    I have also heard that this one is disappointing, and that makes me sad because I have the audio out from the library. I don’t like that the stories seem to get watered down as they go along, and that their threads to the main are tenuous and weak. I might still listen, but it will be with a different mindset, I think. Your review was lovely today.🙂

  2. Charlie

    Good to read your review, it balances out the very positive and negative ones I’ve read. It does look good on the surface, and you would think with chapters by each character you’d get a good insight, too, but it sounds like it misses the mark. Still I think I’d be interested in reading it for the themes.

  3. Rory

    I liked this book, I found it interesting and a good discussion book. However, it also failed to grab me. I haven’t had good luck with Oprah’s book club books.

  4. buriedinprint

    I enjoyed reading your thoughts on this one; I had it from the library once, but either the timing wasn’t quite right for me or it just isn’t a perfect fit for me either. I do enjoy multiple perspectives (I think we’ve discussed this before, about other works) but I feel like there needs to be some note which sustains me throughout the shifts…it doesn’t sound like you found that here, and I’m not sure if I would either, although I’m still a little curious, as I have quite enjoyed some of her other bookclub selections.


One of the things I love about book blogging is that it enables conversation. Please don't hesitate to share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s