200 years of Pride and Prejudice, and my new favourite adaptation

Today marks the 200 year anniversary of the date on which Pride and Prejudice was first published. I have written about my love for this novel before. I can never quite do it justice, for it was one of those books that I feel helped to define me as a reader. I decided against a rereading of the classic on this particular date, because I am trying to limit my rereadings to once every few years. However, I have found a new way to relive the story a few months ago, which I admit has me quite as obsessed with the characters and narrative as I was when I first discovered Jane Austen’s wonderful novel: As most of my twitter followers might have realised because of my endless squeeing over the past weeks, I am, of course, talking about The Lizzie Bennet Diaries.

caption credit

The Lizzie Bennet Diaries is a modern adaptation of Pride and Prejudice in the form of a youtube vlog in which Lizzie Bennet plays the lead. The basic set up is that Lizzie is a master student who starts recording a vlog with the help of her best friend Charlotte Lu. On this vlog, she discusses her mother’s everlasting quest for husbands for her three daughters (Jane, Lizzie, and Lydia; Mary is a cousin and Kitty is Lydia’s cat), but she also talks about her efforts to finish her studies, her job prospects, and the interactions with her sisters and other friends. Some of these characters appear in real life (Lydia and Jane appear on-screen almost from the beginning) and others are impersonated by Lizzie, among whom are her mother and father.

It might surprise some that my title states that I will be talking about my new favourite adaptation, and that it is not the 1995 mini series. But honestly, LBD is definitely vying for that top position, and at this moment it is located firmly at the top of the list. No, it is not a costume drama (although there are a lot of costumes), it is not a period piece, and it is not 100% faithful to the book. Nevertheless, it manages to highlight all the things I so dearly love about this story, and also add in their own interpretation.

One of the strengths of this web-based series is its characterisation. Because it is set up as a video blog, in which Lizzie is often brutally honest, you truly feel you get to know the characters. Furthermore, a lot of them receive a more thorough characterisation than in the novel. Because Jane and Lydia appear on camera as themselves, because you see part of their day-to-day interactions, they become very well-rounded persons (something which is, as Ana mentioned in her post yesterday, always implied in Austen’s novel, but is in some ways more explicit here). Moreover, because of Lizzie’s brutal honesty, which does not necessarily spare anyone, the character growth of both Lizzie and Darcy (and Lydia and Jane!) is highlighted very directly. Lizzie makes mistakes on camera, which she then also has to fix (or grow into fixing) on camera. The character progression of everyone involved is really well-done, and very interesting to watch.

LBD - costume theatre

caption credit

There is an added incentive to care about the characters which has to do with the fact that this is a web-based series. Part of it comes from the realisation that these vlogs are out there, and that the “characters” can watch and find them at any time. The characters themselves become more real because most of them have twitters and tumblrs and such, so that you can follow them as they do things and then compare/contrast this with the portrayal in Lizzie’s vlog. The show has engaged with this transmedia aspect of their production in very interesting ways which increases the realism of the story. I admit that I spent last Saturday stalking some of the characters’ twitters (don’t open them if you’re not up to date with the series), because it promised to have some very interesting story developments.

Because of the way different online media intersect in The Lizzie Bennet Diaries, it has developed a very loyal fan base, and every time I open a video I always find it extremely interesting to see the reactions, the interactions, and the involvement of all these people. Yes, true, many TV shows have loyal fan bases, but because there’s the added illusion that Lizzie is there, somewhere in LA, recording her vlog every Monday and Thursday, the sense of interaction becomes more “real”. (And, the Lizzie Bennet Diaries wouldn’t be as amazing as it is if it did not also address these very illusions of reality in its own videos).

Last but not least is definitely the manner in which the story is translated to a contemporary setting. There are more movies who have done this, more or less successfully, but this one does a stellar job at updating the social issues caught in the book. Yes, class relations are a part of that, and I particularly enjoy the ways in which this is implicitly (and explicitly) made a subject. Moreover, as some of the minor characters receive more attention, they sometimes also receive more agency. Georgiana’s (Gigi’s) back story and its reveal is a good example of this. Most of all, I think this show might work particularly well for me because it involves characters who are at a similar stage in life. Lizzie’s impeding graduation, her fears about the job market, the way in which at times she’s not quite ready yet to take charge of her whole life, all ring very true to me. And then there’s Lydia’s story, which is now progressing on her own blog, and is very painful to watch because it has been updated in a manner that I think might hit very close to home for many girls who have experienced less-than-perfect loves. It is painful, and difficult, but I also find it extremely pertinent, well-addressed, and definitely very brave in this respect.

I could give you a lot MORE arguments why I enjoy this series so much, the first among whom would be a simple: just go watch it. The episodes are short (as it is in the format of a video blog most videos are around 5 minutes long), they are very entertaining, completely heartwarming, funny, and at the same time not afraid to tackle more serious issues. The fact that there are now over 80 episodes may seem daunting at first, but I admit I got hooked somewhere in the autumn and I caught up in a day and a half. Now, I struggle to keep patient for any new episode to appear. I am not afraid to admit that Monday’s and Thursday’s have become the highlights of my week.

Are you watching the Lizzie Bennet Diaries? Do you think you might start to? Are you as obsessed as me? (Please tell me I’m not alone!)

26 thoughts on “200 years of Pride and Prejudice, and my new favourite adaptation

  1. rhapsodyinbooks

    I started watching them yesterday after reading Ana’s post, and couldn’t stop! They are terrific and the girls who act in it are wonderful. I agree with your comments about them and also highly recommend them!

      1. rhapsodyinbooks

        I now finished ALL THE THINGS and subscribed to get new ones! (I even watched the supplemental videos – LOL) Thanks SO MUCH for the heads up!!!! Love them so much! The acting is amazingly spectacular! (And I can sense Hank’s hand in them, can’t you?)

  2. sakura

    I started watching this a few days ago as I’ve been hearing so much about it on twitter and it’s brilliant. I’m so happy there are loads of episodes and seeing how it all unravels.

  3. biblioglobal

    I do think I’m going to have to go check them out now. My current favorite non-traditional interpretation of Austen is Bride and Prejudice, the Bollywood version of P&P.

    1. A.M.B.

      I like Bride and Prejudice, too! My family is South Asian, and it’s funny how similar some of the customs are (even after 200 years). Have you seen the “Posh Dancing” skit from The Mitchell and Webb Look? It’s funny.

  4. A.M.B.

    I haven’t been watching the Lizzie Bennet Diaries, but I’m going to look into it! My favorite parody of Pride and Prejudice is the “Posh Dancing” skit from The Mitchell and Webb Look. It’s hilarious. I love the novel, which I re-read recently. I’m also watching the mini-series all week (even my five-year-old twins are starting to show an interest in it).

  5. Simon T

    I love your enthusiastic post! As you know, I love the series – and the thing I love most is how Lydia has developed.

    Although the latest Lizzie video might vie for top place…

  6. Teresa

    I had a major binge on these yesterday and am now almost halfway through. My favorite thing so far has been the way they handled Charlotte’s choice. Her decision is, I think, one of the more mystifying in the book, until you really step back and look at how much marriage was an economic decision for women. Their clever updating sheds a new light on the original!

    Also, I’m enjoying how Lizzie does so often get things wrong. It makes me think of Simon’s post from a few weeks ago about how Lizzie has as far to go as Darcy but that it’s hard for audiences today to see that. It’s clear in this version, though, that she’s sometimes just plain stubborn and unwilling to reconsider her views.

  7. Christina

    I think I’m as obsessed as you! I also love this adaptation, especially the different perspective it offers on some of the characters. Lydia is much more sympathetic, Bing gets to explain himself a bit more, and we see more Lizzie and Darcy together (which is always a plus in my book!). Off to watch the latest episode now!

  8. Susan

    Thanks for posting about it, Iris. I hadn’t heard about it. I love Pride and Prejudice, it is one of my favourite all time books, along with Persuasion. I was curious to know which version you liked,so now I am going to have to find it on youtube! It sounds like a lot of fun.

    I have always thought that Elizabeth had as far to go as Darcy, as they are both stubborn and proud, only she doesn’t realize it -we as the audience know it, as soon as he slights her, because she won’t forgive him for slighting her. I was thinking recently about Austen’s characters and how very spirited and free-thinking Elizabeth is in particular, in snubbing her nose at the richest man she knows, when convention dictated she should be flattered. I love that they both have to learn the same things, and learn it from one another because they are each other’s equal.

    thanks for inspiring me, I think I have some thoughts for a post on Austen now! lol

  9. bookworm

    So I read Ana’s post about this earlier today and now yours, plus I’ve been seeing your conversations about it on Twitter (I’m not stalking you, I promise) so now I just can’t wait to go home and start watching. Your enthusiasm is contagious!

  10. Melissa

    I love it too! It’s so much fun and I feel like they do such a wonderful job staying close to the original story. I love the P&P is so timeless it can be told in such a new way!

  11. Pingback: Slightly Peckish Tuesday « chasing bawa

  12. Nat

    I love this show ridiculously. I even set a notification, so I get a message in my cellphone each time the youtube channel is updated😛

    But, like you, it’s the characterization that gets me. I think the book makes a very good job showing how wrong Lizzie’s perceptions of Darcy are, but the webseries also portray how wrong she was about everything else. And they do that without making her sound like a brat, but like a wonderful, flawed character.

    I cannot watch Lydia’s videos, though. I like to discuss them, though and in twitter and tumblr both the actress that plays Lydia and the screenwriter in charge of that spin-off encourage discussions among their fans and I think that’s amazing. Still, though, the videos are awfully painful to watch. Someone on tumblr suggested that Lydia is fading just like the color of her hair and that’s just so sad D:

  13. Jenny

    I totally think I want to watch this, what with you and Ana raving so ravily about them. I’m going to see if I can get the episodes streaming on my Roku box, but either way, I’m going to watch them this weekend. The show sounds wondrous.

  14. Pingback: I think you should watch the Lizzie Bennet Diaries | Chachic's Book Nook

  15. Bina

    Thanks for discussing the vlogs series! I had heard about it before, but never really watched it. I will definitely give it a chance now!🙂

  16. Diana

    Great thoughts on LBD! I’ve been addicted for a while. I, too, love the metafictional aspect of the series and the opportunity for fans to interact with the characters. It adds such an interesting dimension to Austen’s tale.

  17. Jenny

    I did not watch LBD on the weekend I said I was going to (got distracted by something, who knows what, I’m distractable), but I have just watched them all in this past week and loooooooved the series. I am crazy excited that they’re going to come out on DVD this summer, and I’m even exciteder that they’re planning a short series for summer and a proper long one for fall. I have my fingers crossed for Jane Eyre. How good would that be?


One of the things I love about book blogging is that it enables conversation. Please don't hesitate to share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s