Orange Reading: Painter of Silence by Georgina Harding

Painter of Silence - Georgina HardingPainter of Silence – Georgina Harding
Bloomsbury USA, September 2012

Review copy from Netgalley
Buy: Amazon | Bookdepository *

Sometime during 1950, a nameless man is found on the doorstep of the hospital in Iasi, Romania. The man is deaf and mute, which makes it harder to identify him. However, a young nurse called Safta recognises him as Augustin, someone she used to know before the war. Safta used to live in a manor as the daughter of a privileged family before World War II. Augustin was the son of the family’s cook. Back in the day, all he had to express himself were his drawings. Now, in the hospital, Safta brings him paper and pencils to enable Augustin to pick up his former pastime. As the story unfolds, we switch back and forth between Safta’s memories of the early days of their lives, while Augustin paints pictures of what happened to him and the people Safta and him knew during the war.

When the Orange Prize longlist was announced Painter of Silence was the title I instantly gravitated towards. The strengths of Painter of Silence were exactly what I expected them to be. There is quiet and beautiful storytelling, a wonderful style that results in some stunningly beautiful passages, and the surprisingly evocative storytelling accomplished through Augustin’s visual observations and drawings. Augustin’s descriptions of scenes, the beauty of some of them, but mostly the haunting and emotional qualities as he pictures the war, are what make this book special and a wonderful read. From the very beginning, the tone is set when the special quality of Augustin’s pictures are described:

“When Tinu drew a room he drew it empty.  He drew it as it was but somehow what you saw was not the room but its emptiness. With a door you saw the opening. When he drew a pitchfork left leaning against the barn wall you saw its abandonment.”

Despite these wonderful qualities, I was left feeling a little bit of an outsider to the story for the first half of it. In a way this is part of its strength; as Augustin tells you his side of the story indirectly, the images have a sort of quiet impact about the war that is devastating in a way that makes immediate sense to the reader. Nevertheless, there were moments when I just wasn’t sure how much I really cared, where I felt that perhaps to make this book a perfect fit for me, I may have needed more. There were moments when the quietness of the story left me confused as to where it was headed. I usually do not require a book to have an immediate and thrilling storyline – really, I mostly enjoy the quieter fiction – but in this case I felt that it was perhaps, at times, a little bit too quiet for my taste.

Painter of Silence left me with an admiration for the accomplishments of Harding’s writing, and the originality of telling a story set during World War II through someone who only has images to tell you what happened. Unfortunately, it did not have as much of an emotional impact on me as I had hoped and expected when I first picked it up.

Other Opinions: Lizzy’s Literary Life, Still Life With Books, Cardigan Girl Verity,  Tales From the Reading Room, Cornflower Books, 1morechapter, Sam Still Reading, nomadreader, Reading Matters.
Did I miss your post on this book? Let me know and I will add it to the list.

* These are affiliate links. If you buy a product through either of them, I will receive a small percentage of the purchase price.

8 thoughts on “Orange Reading: Painter of Silence by Georgina Harding

  1. Violet

    I adored this book. The beautiful painterly quality of the writing, the gorgeous Checkhovian descriptions of their pre-war life, the wonderful way Harding brought the characters to life. There were a few too many coincidences, but I loved the book so much I read her ‘The Spy Game’ and fell in love with that too, only not quite as much.

    Reply
  2. zibilee

    I think that you expressed your feelings for this one very well, and though the book sounds like it was moving, it also sounds like it is a slow starter. Often, that is my main sticking point with the books that I read. It’s almost gotten so bad that I sort of dread picking up a new book. I might still be interested in this one, but your observations really provided me with a lot to think about if I do. Very nice review today.

    Reply
  3. Teresa

    I liked this book quite a lot, although I also wasn’t especially emotionally engaged. For me, that wasn’t a problem, but I can see how it could be if that’s what you’re looking for.

    Reply
  4. Pingback: Library Loot: September 19-25 « The Captive Reader

  5. Chinoiseries

    Storytelling by painting is a rather original way of portraying (and processing) the horrors of WWII. I’m afraid that I’ve read a few too many books this year that deal with that era. I’d still like to read Painter of Silence, but just not right now.

    Reply
  6. Stephanie

    This sounds very good, though I think that style of narration — describing a scene by telling us what he’s drawing — might seem awkward and distance me from the story.

    Reply
  7. Pingback: The First Rule of Swimming by Courtney Angela Brkic | Iris on Books

One of the things I love about book blogging is that it enables conversation. Please don't hesitate to share your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s